The Road; Bill 30

July 7, 2020

Dr. Christine Molnar, AMA President

Dear Members:

Bill 30

A number of important events have occurred since Friday, July 3.

What road are we on as a profession in Alberta? The view from 10,000 feet is concerning.

Yesterday, Bill 30, the Health Statutes Amendment Act, was introduced in the legislature. Many of you have already contacted the Alberta Medical Association with concerns.

The AMA was not consulted about Bill 30. Much like Bill 21, this bill introduces elements of health care reform with no transparency or consultation with important stakeholders, including the AMA. We will be evaluating the implications.

A broad view will be important in looking at all aspects of Bill 30. It is an omnibus bill and has many provisions to consider.

Although we have not yet completed a full evaluation, in media interviews yesterday, on preliminary review, I noted opportunities in the bill.

Most notable is the increased opportunity for Albertans to participate in their health care system. There is an increased focus on patient-centered care.

Participation of public members within the College of Physicians & Surgeons of Alberta will increase from 25% to 50% on Council, panels or committees. As noted by the CPSA itself, this increased public participation is a current trend nationally. It will be important to have these individual appointments by government be truly reflective of appropriate skill sets and representative of our population from an equity and diversity standpoint.

Bill 30 calls for Alternative Relationship Plans under contract instead of under Ministerial Order. This is something the AMA has been seeking for many years in the context of a principles-based approach and individual choice. (Please see my May 15 President’s Letter on this topic.)

Of great concern are the additional changes to the Alberta Health Care Insurance Act. We are currently awaiting legal opinion on this amending legislation. It must be evaluated in the context of an enduring public health care system and the integrity of our profession.

The details of the implementation of these changes and the underlying processes are very important.

The Board of Directors will hold a special meeting tomorrow evening to review our initial analysis of the legislation. We will also consider the findings of last week’s member survey, which points to clear distress in the profession.

I will report back to you. I am eager to hear your thoughts and impressions, too.

Review of medical staff bylaws

You may have seen media coverage in recent days regarding a disturbing incident of racism in a Grande Prairie hospital in 2016. In response to the event, the Minister has called for an immediate review of medical staff bylaws to be completed in 60 days.

The AMA will be supporting the Zone Medical Staff Associations to perform the work needed and will be actively involved in that assessment. Here is some information that has been shared among the zonal leaders, coming initially out of the Edmonton Zone Medical Staff Association.

Bylaws and good process are all characteristics of healthy working environments, but they are not the only characteristics. Medical staff bylaws are only one step on the path toward development of a Just Culture that respects and strives for equity, diversity and inclusion.

I hope that we will see positive changes, like those referenced in my June 30 President’s Letter, with improvements such as an independent office where physicians can report concerns, safe from reprisal, and actions for positive change can be employed.

Please watch for more information soon.

Christine P. Molnar, MD, FRCPC
President, Alberta Medical Association


Commenting on this page is closed.

  • #1

    Vornbrock Nancy

    Member of the public

    9:27 PM on July 07, 2020

    In all honesty the wind went out of sails when I saw Bill 30 without the right to arbitration.

    I’ll keep fighting with you as we see the fall out of this govt. I’ve never been so worried for my healthcare in my life.

    With a chronic disease and the need for so many Drs that hits me from all sides.

    The I told stress and the rudeness and power hungry UCP has to be dealt with. With the HN and staff blocking Drs and public that have opinions has made for a hostile environment and my heart goes out to all our Drs and healthcare workers being run threw the mill.
    The stress level is so high and the UCP needs to give up their power hungry grab and do right by Alberta and the AMA. So far an epic fail in all fronts.

    Good luck to you Colleen. You have worked and battled so hard. Thank you

  • #2

    Josh Fanaeian


    9:31 PM on July 07, 2020

    Thanks for the public letter. Most of if I find encouraging. I am concerned however by a perceived optimistic tone with the introduction of ARPs.
    While I understand the value of ARPs from a theoretical or philosophical standpoint for physicians, it seems extremely troubling that many physicians appear to be on track to be cornered into them in the near future. The government has already made fee for service unsustainable for many colleagues as a first step as you’ve mentioned. It seems naive for physicians to enter or consider ARP contracts that are conceived with no physician or AMA input. We have seen this government’s agenda and they don’t seem to value evidence-based public health policy, physicians or patients.

  • #3

    Vornbrock Nancy

    Member of the public

    9:35 PM on July 07, 2020

    My apologies Christine. So sorry I called you the wrong name. Sick friend with that name on my mind. Good luck to you.
    Being a long time patient in the Alberta medical world from rural to city hospitals. In and out and too many surgeries. I’ve been through it all and seen it all.
    I’ve been fighting this with the Drs since December. If I can help more than I have please don’t hesitate to ask.


The AMA advances patient-centered, quality care by advocating for and supporting physician leadership and wellness.